MikroTik

I have now heard back from Mikrotik RMA and Streakwave RMA people.. The only way to get the most expensive products Mikrotik makes repaired out of warranty - even if its 1 day out of warranty - takes months and involves paying for a ton of shipping. Back and forth with Streakwave and then you have ...

Not working on windows 7 (still on all my windows machines). Not working on macOS 10.13.6 (latest that can run on my 2011 macbook pro). BTW, the last macbook with wired ethernet (2012) probably has too old macOS as well. Please consider supporting older OS versions, unless there is something fundam...

Love it. Winbox on MacBook looks great !!!

I get outages from DUDE checking PSU Status 7.15.3 on a CCR2116-12G-4S+. It just doesnt answer SNMP Requests for a while then again. 2 other CCR2116-12G-4S+ with 7.14.3 behave normal. CPU is low. oid("1.3.6.1.4.1.14988.1.1.3.15.0") oid("1.3.6.1.4.1.14988.1.1.3.16.0") Wireshark sh...

Yes, MPLS on CCR2xxx si very limited!

A couple years ago we were hoping for hardware offloading of MPLS, but now... we have lost hope, so we are looking at other devices.

It's a shame. With L3HW Unloading it is a real beast. Very low CPU load with Full BGP Tables. Consistent low latency.

Disabling MPLS enables L3HW. So MPLS on CCR2116 is a nogo for now. A small note in Documentation would help a lot

The packet loss is caused by MPLS enabled. Even without MPLS packets travelling from/through this router and minimal Mappings (31 loopback addresses for VPLS connections terminated at another router) it causes packet drops. Large BGP Tables and MPLS is not usable on a 2116 / ROS V7.14.3. I wanted to...

I see Packet loss on a 2116 with moderate load (500MBit/s). I tried to enable l3HW Offload. Anyone seen this error: /interface/ethernet/switch/print Columns: NAME, TYPE, L3-HW-OFFLOADING, QOS-HW-OFFLOADING # NAME TYPE L3-HW-OFFLOADING QOS-HW-OFFLOADING ;;; L3HW init error(3) 0 switch1 Marvell-98DX32...

I worked around with a virtual Win11-Arm-64bit in Vmware Fusion. Winbox and Dude works with the integrated emulation. Attached a USB-Networkadapter. Works fine so Dude works with MAC-Address based connect, too. MacBooks are crazy fast so the emulation runs fine.

most people asking for 64bit client is not for use in windows per se, is for use in windows emulated on ARM Mac which only emulates 64bit so its a very niche use I use windows 64bit and use the dude client 32bit without problem Yes. But the niche is growing. Got a new MAC-Book. Basic stuff like clo...

Hello, MikroTik is planning to develop and build a controller app for MikroTik Devices. Currently we are researching possibilities and options, what should be there and how it could be done and implemented. At the moment we do not want to stick to a specific implementation or standard, but build ou...

Weather radar uses only a very small channel at 5,6. So it would be possible to live for both kind of users.

@ Ca6ko: frequency=auto or 5745-5825 installation=outdoor guard-interval=long hide-ssid=no Some weeks ago I tested every single channel and radar-detect came on each one within less than one hour. Frequency= auto has already been tested. It starts at 5180 detects radar, disconnects and tries again ...

Hello, thanks for the reply. What timer you change ospf or mpls: 2nd Matching hello and dead timers with MPLS and OSPF /routing/ospf/interface-template hello-interval=10 (i would change this timer to=5) dead-interval=40 (i would change this timer to=15) /mpls/ldp/interface hello-interval=5 (accordi...

Dual Hotswap PSU !

I always do a staggered Update. Update home Router, wait, Update uncritical routers one by one with wait between. A rollout lasts 2 months at least. MT has no SW quality management worth this name. *We* have to test. If you can't live with this, use another vendor. For sure you will pay for this qua...

@MT it would be very helpful to make the config converter available. Would be a great learning tool and gives a preview what happens on upgrade. May be within winbox.

No network command in 7.1?

With your environment, a CCR will literally fall over. It simply can not deal with BGP, Firewall Rules, and Traffic in high quantities. High traffic and maybe 100 firewall rules, will be enough to stop the CCR dead in it's tracks. It's definitely not the 'flagship' that MT is making it out to be. A...

Mikrotik continues to ignore fast x86, and still releases routers on old slow cores from the past: CCR2116 (Annapurna Labs Alpine AL73400, based on ARM Cortex-A72 from 2016) CCR2004 (Annapurna Labs Alpine AL324, based on ARM Cortex-A57 from 2012) CCR10XX (Tilera TILE-Gx from 2012) RB5009 (Marvell A...

You should test 7590AX or even better the 6000 Repeater. The difference esp. with 2GHz is huge. We are in 2021 so 802.ax is the current tech.

Did not touch MT 5GHz wireless for a while now as we move to other gear in this band. But there are still some APs around running nv2. Tried to update an AP with 3 CPEs using nv2. Now I see lower fluctuating speeds. Using plain 802.11ac seems to do better. So all who stayed with MT Wireless. What is...

I assume you guys have also limited mapping with the mpls advertise filter? I tend to bring up the hello timers, because by default they do not match. Between the mpls advertise filters and timers match, I have eliminated losing mpls sites in my system. I may not be as big a fish as some of you, bu...

been there done that. we ripped out MPLS due to instability, moved everything to EOIP and now slowly replacing MT with Arista/VXLAN.

We tried EOIP, too. Was a desaster regarding jitter.

millenium7 : Did you ever set the hello timers in mpls to match the hello timers in ospf? Thats saved me a lot of grief over the years. But does not help in some cases. Just again had to disable/enable MPLS as OSPF had learned a route but MPLS did not. Even disabling the interface did not help. MPL...

still resets OSPF Neighborship. ROS 6.47.10.

@MT Please ...

Just added an additional redundant link between 2 MT Routers. Still needs to disable/enable LDP on one of the routers to make the IPs of this link reachable. So I have to make an interrupt to several hundret people to make this work. Disabling/Enabling of the (LDP)interface does not help. I have to ...

We are long time MT User. We only use Long Term Version. Read the changelogs. Even with LT there are showstoppers fixed lately.

The problem is the moderator BartoszP https://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=176315#p864067 for example: >>>@rextended ... please do not start unneccessary conversation.<<< I don't have to write anything because for him the problem was SOCKS and it couldn't be anything else ... (but ins...

It is difficult when the problem is a Moderator rather than a simple user like me...

I am green ;-). How can I help ...

Having a player public IP List it's not possible for a lot of reasons. Sorry thats the only idea I have, but you have not answered the question. WHY is it impossible?? I clearly stated that anyone can get a free domain name dyndns and that they can give to you if they want to play. If this is a bus...

i don't understand why you say this.., but no problem, I really appreciate a lot your help or anyone who gives their advice to avoid this attack problem. you can read my signature for why, sorry but I'm sad about that, but you have nothing to do with it. You need a thicker skin ;-). I guess this fo...

MT compiles it for newer versions but do no changes/corrections for years now. But ... it works and there is no replacement. We moved it to a CHR as the RB1100AHx4 Dude Edition is to weak.

Thanks for the infos. As routing/forwarding table is accurate on the problematic router update imho point 1 is the main point...

A few questions... What hardware and long term version? Are you running VPLS? Are your OSPF and LDP timers matched? CCR-1036-8G-2S+ 6.46.8 OSPF/LDP Timers default: OSPF: 5/1/10/40 LDP: 5/15 VPLS: yes (This is our reason to use MPLS). I have seen this kind of behaviour at differnet sites over the ye...

Today I again chased a forwarding Problem in our Network integrating a new PTP Link. Behaviour is still flaky. While integrating the link I started without doing OSPF/MPLS over the link itself. The IPs used by the link (gateway on both sides, Link addresses) where not reachable by parts of the netwo...

Do you use OSPF on this interface?

ESXI 6.5. vSwitch allows to set higher MTU. But it looks like l2mtu is not detected by CHR (shows "0"). mtu is settable. But then the (senseless?) OSPF MTU check jumps in and hinders building neighborship. And it looks like only one OSPF neighbor with different MTU cause problems. Setting ...

Cant get it running with MPLS MTU 1526 The l2mtu of the interface shows "0" changing l2mtu does nothing. I can change MTU to 1600. As soon as I do this I get OSPF errors: route,ospf,info Discarding Database Description packet on ether1 (x.x.x.x): different MTU So I would need to change all...

What do you mean by "effective possession" ?
Ubiquiti has some sort of deal with Procera which is the only producer of high powered 60Ghz radios supporting channels 5 and 6. They invested in Procera (and consequently sued them in ubiquiti fashion)

Peraso

There is a Post Reply button below the windows to reply on a post. No need to Quote every post.

You are funny. I had a one line quoter shorter than your footer ;-)

Hi

Rb4011?

1100AHx4

What version of RouterOS?
Was the router open from internet to manage (Winbox/web/SSH/Telnet) (or just from LAN IP?

Can you ask someone local to power cycle it?

Found someone to power cycle it. No internet exposure. Looks like a SW Problem.

One of our routers suddenly eat 25% CPU (1 CPU at 100%). Process is unclassified. I cant reboot it. Not with winbox and not with cli.
Just says it will reboot soon but does not reboot.

Before I drive to the router. Anything I could do remote?

Does this SFP Module show correct negotiation results (unlike older modules) or do we have to do speedtests to see line problems?

Every WISP had water inside horizontal cable entries. It is just a matter of time until water finds its way inside.
We suffered from this years ago. Cable entries *always* has to be at the bottom.

We tested AF60LR units -they includes a new precise aiming mount - and a way faster to align the units.

The main advantage are additional channels which make a difference in 60GHz...

CRS devices are intended to be L2 switches with some L3 functionality, such as providing DHCP, but NOT wire-speed L3 routing/firewalling as they performance-limited by the CPU. If you use CAPsMAN manager forwarding it imposes a significant CPU load on the CAPsMAN controller, so with a CRS as the co...

A netpower 16P with a fast CPU.

It's been 84 years... Have been waiting for long-term 6.47.X to release, so I could upgrade to it directly from stable 6.46.5 on RB760iGS and cAP AC, given how poor a lot of recent stable 6.47.X (and .48, oh man, oh god) releases were received. But, generally speaking, is it a good idea (meaning &q...

Very stable on all HW we throw this release on. Great Version!

Some notes to the wireless part. Radardetect/DFS is an increasing issue - The used chipsets cant distinguish wireless signals from Radar in a lot of situations - You could decrease the false detection rate using *correct* Gain-Data as this goes into the calculation - With newer Firmware, Vendors hav...

I would like to ask the question why is Fritzbox so highly rated ? Is there a comparable cheaper product? Main reason imho is the integration of DECT which is the standard for wireless phones in our country. Webinterface is quite simple and could be used by "normal" people. There is no co...

Thank you modsx for stripping the Nray, i am shocked just to see the very small phased array antenna at the heart of the Dish!

I was expecting multiple phased array board not just one.

Regards

Paul

With Ignitenet you'll find a 60GHz USB Stick within the Antenna ...

official announcements will be released only after product will be closer to finishing stage.
Hardware and software currently is close to that point.

Great !!! Hopefully spring time is install time :-).

Mikrotik product portfolio somehow got weird. Mikrotik have switches now which can do HW NAT Mikrotik have switches that can do HW Routing. Mikrotik have Routers that CAN NOT do HW NAT or HW Routing but does everything on CPU :) I think the new CCR 200x series has to have a capable SoC somehow. CHR...

Full feed? Time for learning all routes? The issue for us is not the time to load all the routes (quite fast), but the convergence time in case of flap... horribile. [/quote] Beta 7 is much better in this regard. I tested. Have you tried enabling FastTrack Connection and disable Connection Tracking...

The biggest question in my mind. Do you think v7 is stable enough for your production environment? V7 is awesome, just not sure if I would put it into production yet.

This question is rhetoric. ***NO***!!

We have multiple instances where we have CHRs running with 2+ full internet v4/v6 feeds. Here are my observations. 1.Make sure your convenience time issues are not related to being able to pass traffic. I have seen many instances where the underlying hardware was not enough to keep up with the traf...

Have you been doing dense high (meaning 250-500+Mbps) wireless? Have you built out fiber in a neighborhood? If not, then I'm guessing you are talking about a different "WISP" scenario, not comparable to what I'm talking about. So Terragraph doesn't apply. If so, then you should know that ...

UI has some advanced upper channel stuff in Airfiber 60 LR that is great, and I think is still AD chipset though?

Yes. And higher power. Not sure this is peraso stuff.

Couldn't find anything about pricing. Anyone dare to guess?

Cambium published prices. Imho far to expensive and needs to much power.

Are there any bigger Terragraph (pure mesh) networks up and running today?

This stuff/chipset is new. Heard of some test networks with press releases but not sure this was done with .ad.

For BGP performance choose CCR2004 or CHR

CCR10xx is slow on single-core performance as needed by BGP.

There are a lot reports of instabilities with ccr2004 on this forum ...

Hello, I have a question cuz i truly dont fiind any answears for it. I whant to buy an CCR1036-8G-2S+EM and use it in ower DC with 2 providers, BGP, at the moment we use Vyos installed on a server with 8GB Ram and an six core Cpu. We have global table with more then 1.6m routes Neighbor V AS MsgRcv...

Hello, I have a question cuz i truly dont fiind any answears for it. I whant to buy an CCR1036-8G-2S+EM and use it in ower DC with 2 providers, BGP, at the moment we use Vyos installed on a server with 8GB Ram and an six core Cpu. We have global table with more then 1.6m routes Neighbor V AS MsgRcv...

Interesting stuff: https://blog.kroy.io/2019/08/23/battle- ... l-routers/
May be the older chr-Kernel slows things down a bit.

Throw as much cpu power at vmware/chr as possible ...

This NUC is a more PRO-One (XEON) than the 1036 (old with single PSU) running now. 45W TDP makes it a quite energy efficient system. Housing is a bit bigger for thermal reasons. There are some interesting systems from Supermicro but not available... It's not just about the xeon procs but rather the...

NUCs are really good for home use and this one seems to have a lot of power but may not be the most suitable choice for a "carrier grade" installation. Pick something with at least double PSU and sufficient cooling system. And needless to say always have a backup unit at hand. This NUC is...

Well. I have replaced a single 1036 for core, into two routers: 1x CCR2004 in fastpath to take care of the BGP only. the 1036 do to all the firewall and eventual NAT needed. Now it all runs flawlessy Yes, when you are doing BGP with multiple peers on internet and you want to do NAT and stateful fir...

Well.
I have replaced a single 1036 for core, into two routers:
1x CCR2004 in fastpath to take care of the BGP only.
the 1036 do to all the firewall and eventual NAT needed.
Now it all runs flawlessy

Full feed? Time for learning all routes?

The problem of course is that it requires a very specific workload to keep 72 cores busy and it does not help that there are tasks that are not multithreaded. Those people that run BGP on internet (not me, fortunately) have performance issues that can only be solved with faster cores, not with more...

Anyone using CHR on
https://www.supermicro.com/en/products/ ... 8CN8TP.cfm

With e.g. VMWare as host system. There are onboard 10G Interfaces I need to use.

Have to replace CCR as BGP is still to slow and I cant wait until V7 is stable.

The horn will put more signal towards your customer for the same dB rating because none is lost to sideloges and backside radiation. It will reject all off-axis signals. The first part is not exactly true. Antenna gain (measured in dBi), to which you're referring as dB rating, is maximum signal lev...

It is comparing a big speaker box to a smartphone speaker. Both make sound.
Hard to say
Did you ever use them?
We saw much better CCQ with horns!
We will never go back!

Yes. Same experience.

We use RF Horns for a while and they are good.
RF horn 90* vs SXT 90* who wins and why?

Cleaner pattern, same gain with different frequencies, low sidelobe, much better FB Ratio.
It is comparing a big speaker box to a smartphone speaker. Both make sound.

'ad and 'ay are not compatible though, so that pretty new nRay and Cube AC are stuck on 'ad offerings.

Sure ?

... Might be time to look into alternatives MT for a long time says that there is no active development in The DUDE. So yes, it is time. But there is no MonitoringSW like The Dude :-(. Very mighty stuff out there. But much more work and not as easy and fast to use. RightClick-Tools-Dude does not wo...

All monitoring products like zabbix and PRTG are poorly made and garbage interfaces. Space is ripe for something not crappy They may be great but using a webinterface instead of a program/app as frontend is a modern but bad idea. Webdevelopers do strange things trying to emulate a real application....

Certification for the country can be found in the Mikrotik. ETSI is overall Europe. /interface wireless info> country-info etsi ranges: 2402-2482/b,g,gn20,gn40(20dBm) 5170-5250/a,an20,an40,ac20,ac40,ac80,ac160,ac80+80(23dBm)/passive,indoor 5170-5330/a,an20,an40,ac20,ac40,ac80,ac160,ac80+80(20dBm)/d...

802.11ax, Terragraph?

A technical forum this is
on mikrotik topic should stay

:D :lol:

Yoda this is

Hi all, we have a big problem and have no more ideas. We have 2 OSPF networks, all APs and RBs of the networks are in MPLS network and APs have VPLS. If we do restart a AP, a RB or a MPLS make restart, we have in complete Network 1-3 seconds a timeout to internet and all devices. Connections hang a...

When submitting a posting or change then I get a redirect to forum.mikrotik.com:80 and the posting/change is made but I don't get returned to the expected page anymore. When I remove ":80" in the URL then I get an page that I expected. An error occurred during a connection to forum.mikrot...

The answers in this topic will change depending on the specific product. There are different limitations for smaller and for bigger gain devices. I can clarify specific limitations if you tell me exactly which product you plan to use. I plan to use these new 802.11ay terragraph 4sector devices from...

The Annex3 has been changed from CEPT last summer and the CE has armonized the rules all over the europe, here the new decision https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dec_impl/2019/1345/oj that is mandatory, every countries in europe MUST use it since 1.1.2020 Now we have new rules in europe for SRD from 57...

That's the part in the Quick Guide that troubles me as well .... "In the following countries this device cannot be used in Fixed Point-to-Point applications: " whatever that means. I don't understand. Klembord-2.jpg In Germany eg it was not allowed to mount 60 Ghz devices as P2P for a fix...

I had to increase Advertised L2MTU for VPLSTunnel at the side of the new bridge config. With old bridge config it works with 1514. With new Bridge config I need 1530. So at one side of VPLS Tunnel I have L2MTU=1514 now and at the other side 1530. Bridges show L2MTU of 1514 on one and 1530 on other s...

Anyone running successful vlans which are part of a new bridge config (ingress filtering) through vpls tunnels? Anything to look at? I have strange effects adding another VPLS tunnel to existing tunnels going to a central bridge. This new tunnel is originated from a RB450Gx4 using the new bridge/vla...

@MT seen some announcements on terragraph/802.11ay lately. As MT is partnering there, I am eager to hear some news and see the new chipsets in PTP devices like the nray.

... And this answer I am getting about dude questions from mikrotik always. For many, many years.

Yes. It's a shame. Despite its faults dude is still a great tool. All these fancy web interface based monitoring tools are *uncomfortable* to handle.

This is probably not the answer you wanted but I would not run the DNS service on the router. In smaller setups if can make sense but in larger setups like yours I would say two dedicated servers would be the best option. Note that you not need high cost servers for this. In come cases it might eve...

Hi Leandro, There are some _major_ issues with MPLS in RouterOS v6. The major ones being the lack of Fast Re-Route, RSVP paths not failing over(or back), NLRI not being updated for L3VPN's and stale labels causing traffic to disappear. It is usable for basic stuff like VPLS, but it is all done 100%...

This is crazy low. You should by all means inrease bandwidth or you'll run into problems. I would go with at least 100Mbits.

You answered a 2013 post

As I said in my post, the "bridge" interface provides access to the CPU, i.e. the device itself, you have: /interface bridge vlan add bridge=bridge1 tagged= bridge1 untagged=ether2 vlan-ids=1 add bridge=bridge1 tagged=ether2, bridge1 untagged=vplsTunnelXXX vlan-ids=4 add bridge=bridge1 ta...

Thanks for your help.

Did just/only this and nothing changed:

add frame-types=admit-only-vlan-tagged ingress-filtering=yes name=bridge1 vlan-filtering=yes

The bridge config seems to let the ethernet port itself work additional/as before without beeing part of the bridge.

Thanks for your help.

Did just/only this and nothing changed:

add frame-types=admit-only-vlan-tagged ingress-filtering=yes name=bridge1 vlan-filtering=yes

The expected behavior all depends on how you did the configuration and without seeing this makes it impossible to comment. I do suspect that you stopped halfway, if you read further in the quoted URL, you will see where it talks about "Unintentionally allowed management access..." And exp...

Hi, configured a RB450Gx4 with the new bridge/vlan scheme (ROS 6.47). https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/ROS/Bridge+VLAN+Table#heading-TrunkAccessportsetup Looks normal despite I could access the router with the Ethernet address of the raw ethernet port on a port configured as plain access port....

We also run into situations where we need to stop start LDP. E.g. with IP Changes on MPLS Interfaces and with new start of a router. Happens seldom so no big issue for us but it looks like there is a bug keeping labels up to date.

Channels? Channel Size? TX Power? Wireless Chipset?

Noone knows?

Bridging is not switching. When switching all the traffic pass through the switch chip, and that's it. When bridging the traffic passes through the CPU. It does little more than copying the packets from one port to another - but it crosses the CPU. To be clear: switching takes place inside the swit...

That seems to be the product its built to compete with. Anyone done the comparisons yet? In the Mesh world and for busy home networks, based on my field experiences nobody beats Netgear RBKxx systems -- NOBODY period FULL Stop Ruckus --- The only manufacturer that has successfully exploited Spatial...

If you want to do 1G you should look for Wifi6/802.11ax APs. Make sure your PC could do it.

You must have misunderstood. It was not promised for 2019.
The MUM Europe roadmap is for the next 12 months. So until ~April 2020.

So there we are

This is a long lasting discussion. Solution: No. nv2/nstreme is not developed for years now. If you are able to use plain 802.11 in your environment you may get happy. If not MT Wireless will not make you happy.

Fighting CPU Usage on a CCR1036-8G-2S+ I see "firewall-mgmt" uses a lot cpu. Esp it bogs one cpu up to 100%. "firewall" does not show that much usage. What does this process and how to reduce load?

First make this a reliable switch. Connecting 10G and 1G is still a mess. We get packet loss and vpls tunnels with sporadic outages. I cant even see if flow control is negotiated? How do you test this switch without this information? We consider to remove all our CRS317 at the moment.

*) system - improved system stability when receiving/sending TCP traffic on multicore devices; Hello MT guys! Could you give more details about this? I would like to know if there is an improviment for CCR and x86 devices as well. Cheers +1 Had problems with a BGP Router with very high cpu usage at...

It's mainly about software. And the software we all have outdated (from Mikrotik) V7 - no changes yet. We are waiting for the spectral scan from 2014, and others ... Still waiting.... :-( No. With wireless it is about HW, too. Actual HW done for WISPs shows speed and features we need in 2020. It ta...

I am chasing sporadic Paket losses in a part of our network. In between is a CRS317. Opening Interface List I see "0" Tx Drops in Interface List. Clicking into the interface I see a lot of Tx Drops in the Tx Stats Tab. This happens on an Interface with S-RJ01, Flow Control is off, no Pause...

With snow we have problems with short links. I would not go beyond a mile.

Only one single developer from MikroTik "Reinis" knows when he will finish his own implementation of MU-MIMO ... Why only one? You got any internal info that's so bad? Look into changelogs and see how many entries are for wireless. If there would be a bigger team only for wireless I would...

With the new RouterOS v6.46 do you see some total traffic improvements on point-to-multipoint nv2 or other mt setups? Wha we should see that? We can’t test it, we removed all Mikrotik P2P As others said. You have said your opinion and everyone could search and find. So repeating again and again ......

Digging into a RB1100AHx4 I see tx-pause packets on switch-cpu interface using "interface ethernet switch port print stats". So the internal switches do flow-control to the cpu. I see this with 200MBit traffic and <4% load. I guess the buffers of the internal switches are small so it might...

i can't say if rx-drop it is necessarily a problem or failure or not i think when searching about this there is no there is no concrete or definitive explanation I think that in the statistical sense, the number of discarded packets vs. the total packages must be checked to establish a percentage r...

Which part of my post showed that i was unaware of what I'm doing?
clear los 400m excellent signal/aim.
device has to be reliable without disconnects on light /medium rain.
I don't get the defence over this product by you?

What is the signal you calculated for this link?

Hello all. Pretty dissapointed after first rains here. 400m link between to LHG60ad's and cant seem to keep connection alive. Keeps reconnecting almost every minute. Tried 5 frequencies and lock tx-sector but with no success. During rain Signal goes up and down from 80 down to 20 and then disconnec...

Hyper-V introduces yet another software license to worry about and pay for... and an OS that has to be rebooted at least once a month. +1 VMWare Hypervisor is free and stable. Running on good HW (We use DELL Rack-Servers) gives troublefree service. There are scripts to backup Files to a NAS so we h...

Same here running 6.44.5 on 1100AHx4 Dude Edition. We connected it to a remote switchable PowerSupply.

RouterOS without WinBox is like car without seats, it still runs, but it's not enjoyable ride. But it's clear now that it's not good idea to let it be exposed to whole world. I though that it shouldn't be a problem anymore, that MikroTik surely fixed it, to require robust authentication first befor...

Would need a CSS610-8P-2S+ now

).

Yes! Me too! DISC AC LITE is the bugger. The arm SXT's are a lot more stable on the identical configuration. Dyna's fine. LHG fine. Just the damn DISC AC LITE. The main problem I experience is when the control frame timeouts start happening. After a while the disc just disconnects from the AP and t...

Yes, just like WirelessRudy confirms, we have said this before. Nv2 was designed for older chipsets, to solve problems that were there at the time. New chipsets and 802.11ac do not have the same issues, so there is no real benefit to use Nv2 now. There are still problems with plain .ac and outdoor ...

The attractive property of MikroTik routers (and switches), its low price, is made possible by the use of standard SoC chips which have only a basic processor and some optimization of encryption. Everything runs in software, made possible by the Linux system which has a very advanced networking sta...

It's not hardware nat. Hardware NAT implemented completely in hardware, work on wire speed, and do not use CPU. following your logic, CCRs don't have encryption in HW either, right? btw, can you please point out any _non_cpu_hardware_element_ in the CCR series routers? network operations "done...

There is a X86 Package. So you could go with plain PC hardware. For sure a core i7 will outperform CCR.

Still did not get the point. What is the advantage to:

https://mikrotik.com/product/RBmAP2nD

after all the conversation the only conclusion that is clear to me is that nv2 is an old protocol but has no alternative. Therefore mikrotik lentils, if you want you take them if you don't leave them. This is news from last year ... If the performance of nv2 is enough (which happens often) it is ok...

it is not clear to me if mikrotik is still betting on the wisp or not ... They build/announced LTE Basestations. I guess MT will not get into the big carrier market so this targets WISPs. The do not put much effort into the wifi based stuff. Seems not the market to grow. UBNT Development of their L...

Thank you very much scampbell your information is very important to me. I only have to know if mikrotik bet on the wisp or have us abandoned to our fate. I think the war between ubnt and mikrotik is over and in the end we were wrong on the side There is no war, there are other vendors and there is ...

Nv2 work well if we consider the old AP hardware (netmetal, sxt sa, ecc)

No. MT missed the step to 802.11ac. It does not work better than 11n with MT gear despite HW/CPUs are newer/better. NV2 is reliable but slow.

CRS328 CPU at 100% ?

i think there is a lot of marketing hype around each new wifi generation, this causes a lot of confusion and excessive expectations

Of course. But for sure every generation was a big step forward. Not as big as announced but big.

Yes, M could be for Mesh possibly. Could it be for Terragraph? terragraph depends on the QCA64xx baseband from qualcomm and most features it is essentially part of the .11ay standard. the current terragraph has modified MAC&PHY layers, frame structure, basically everything - so it is absolutely...

I hope you will get troublefree operation from your network. I operate a WiFi network from another competitor and I find that whenever you enable features like fast roaming, band steering etc you will always have some devices that have problems. Not an issue when you have a controlled environment (...

80Mhz is near impossible to pull off full performance outdoors in 5Ghz. You’d have to be in the wilderness 20 miles from any homes and well below the tree line.

Or use high gain antennas with good isolation on short links.

- 802.11ac Hardware perform worse then 802.11n Well, not really.I did some tests with a single Laptop, Windows 10, Intel 8265 connected at 866 Mbit/s, clear spectrum 1. MikroTik cAP ac with IPQ4019, RouterOS 6.45.5, CH36 (80 MHz) 2. Cambium E410 with IPQ4019, CambiumOS 3.11.2, CH36 (80 MHz) ... Qui...

What would you do if mikrotik does not release a stable tdma protocol or new Access Points. Netmetal is a very old AP. And in the future products shown in the mums they don't have plans for new wireless products. Mikrotik seems to be focused on routing and the wireless market seems to be not their ...

So qualcomm announced their second generation of 802.11ax Chipsets:

https://www.qualcomm.com/products/qualc ... 0-platform

Guys, perhaps you heard about a tiny vendor called Hew Pac Ent I think. They started selling pre-802.11ax hardware since last year. After 1 year they finally published an updated roadmap for 802.11ax software features: https://i.ibb.co/dLQktvt/m5Bgvos.png So you hopefully understand that making sof...

I didn't say wAP and I didn't say when But yes, we are always working on new and exciting products

Dont step back

So ordered my first laptop with 802.11ax. Where is wAP ax?

Hi guys Any solution to this? I'm designing some major customer solution right now. I've build monitoring around LibreNMS,- but recently changed to Dude. So far, running everything with a RB1100AHx4 Dude edition. Reading this worries me :? Cheers Biker You are crazy. You cant sell service based on ...

With these 40G High-Speed Ports we will get quite big speed differences into the network. So Buffering/Flow Control will be an issue/must have. We saw this while upgrading our main uplink to 10G. Using CRS317 we even cant see the flow control negotiation status. We got packet loss in the direction o...

I know some operators even work 'out of band' in 100% illegal frequencies, some in 'grey' area (legal but too much power....) etc. just to keep the business going. Nobody denounces since everybody will see it then boomerang back..... Is there no telecom authority in Spain? Here in the Netherlands w...

!ste:

Is it necessary to quote FULL previous post?

No. As forum SW handles this quite good (scrollbars) my lazyness does not hurt too much

I don't understand al that whining abt MT not making it into the future... I am a small 750 clients WISP in an area where at least 8 other providers are around. 60% of my network is now full 'ac' (with a load of 'arm' devices) and I run on most of my 40+ sectors plain 802.11 which still everytime a...

Updateing to 6.44.5 brings a problem with PPOE Server. Using a Remote Address in PPP Secret which is from a pool this address is not reserved/blocked. So PPPOE-Server uses this IP twice. Hard to find the problem as pings alway go through from the server side but customers complain like mad. So the ...

Updateing to 6.44.5 brings a problem with PPOE Server. Using a Remote Address in PPP Secret which is from a pool this address is not reserved/blocked. So PPPOE-Server uses this IP twice. Hard to find the problem as pings alway go through from the server side but customers complain like mad. So the s...

44.5 caused Mipse and CCR's to port flap.. I'm not sure why, but when we go to 44.3 it stops.. Going to 445 or above, including the latest BETA crashed an entire leg of our network. Ports were flapping that had nothing plugged in to them, and some where BH's were and it would just flap OSPF constan...

As the product naming page explains: CRS series: 3 total number of interfaces: 12 number of combo 10G Ethernet/SFP ports: 4 (4C+ part of name) number of 5G/10G Ethernet ports: 8 (8XG part of name) The mentioned CRS317-1G-16S+RM fetaures only 1Gbps ports (ethernet) or 10Gbps (SFP+). So it's like com...

Some data I cant find on the Datasheet:

Switch chip?
Ethernet-Ports: what speeds at what distance? Jumbo Frames?

CRS317-1G-16S+RM has more ports, better cpu and is cheaper. So?

Thread was started to get ideas about potential requirements in hypothetical devices that may come in the future, not a specific product. To see what standards people see as becoming more needed etc. Yea. But my first wish is to make interfaces work perfect which are there. I still cant see how flo...

The older S+RJ10 are crap. Wrong DDM information, low MTU, ... There was a post showing newer with MTU size depending on negotiation speed. So it is guesswork and luck making it work ...
Is S-RJ01 also that troublesome?

No. But not sure if the packet loss with 100Mbit devices is solved.

Did anyone try actual 10/100 modules with CRS317? Or 10/100/1000 other than S-RJ01? I tried one 10/100 Cisco and some F5 Networks 1000 BASE-T but they don't seem to work with at 10/100 speed (not all that surprising). I used auto-negotiation=off speed=100mbps. S+RJ10 also doesn't work when configur...

I can confirm my S+RJ10 module (R2 18/12/06 shown on label and R2.11 shown on SFP tab in ROS) allows jumbo frame of 9000 at link speed of 2.5Gbps.

So if they negotiate down to 1G they no longer transport Jumbo Frames? Difficult to find the problem if that happens ...

Could you give me more information about "known problem with the SRJ01 module linking on 100MBit"? What is a solution for that? Changing the module doesn´t help. On one side we have a RB2011 (only copper ports) and on the other side a CRS212-1G-10S with such a module. Sporadically it goes...

@tojoe You can distinguish new S+Rj10 revision by “/r2” at the end of the serial number. There shouldn't be any issues with passing Jumbo frames, if modules are from r2 revision. Please send us email, describing your setup and problem in more detail, at support@mikrotik.com Not true. We have /r2 ve...

Doing some changes to IPs/Interfaces MPLS/LDP comes to a state to not forward traffic to the interface/IP-Range of this interface. I manualy have to disable/enable LDP to make forwarding work correct. This does not heal even waiting for hours. So doesent LDP exchange information cyclic and then brin...

Its not that your router will go down if you do not install a fix for IPv6 to your router. You need IPv6 enabled. You need some that know you are running IPv6. You need someone targeting you with an attack. Quite simple. Do a traceroute to a customer. Identify the BGP-Gateway. Start Attack. Any WIS...

Hi!

Can you give me a hint on how to transfer ALL vlans through a LHG-Link? Do I have to configure the VLANs, or is it enough to leave "VLAN Filtering" disabled on the bridge?

Thank you for your help!

Yes. Do a plain bridge and do no tagging then all packets go through.

Hej guys, I have 750m PTP link to do and three small 230V wires by the road between these two points. Is it ok to use LHG60 kit ? I don't need 1Gbps throughput, 300Mbps will be ok. What about rain and snow, I want to sleep well :-) Snow is a problem. Expect to get problems in winter. Do a 5GHz Back...

While Terragraph sounds interesting, it certainly can't replace P2P links (whitepaper says range is about 250m, using small antennas). The range will depend on the used antennas. PTP links will be part of the mesh. I hope different Vendors will be compatible as Radwin and Cambium has announced terr...

On 60GHz WAP radio PCB, there is place for 5GHz radio chips, but it was never used. Mikrotik appears to be just sleeping, while competition is creeping closer and closer and may beat them at their own 60GHz game... Hopefully this will be a wakeup call and we will see some new 60GHz gear soon. They ...

Doing backhaul + backup with one Antenna in one direction is not a good idea anyway.
Mostly it's rain backup... OK I 'll wait for ubiquiti

May take a while ...

LHG60 is great and available (for a while now). It runs ROS which is way better than AirOS. So wrong thread to blame them sleeping. This new gear looks very small. So I guess gain is between WAP 60G and LHG60G. If you need 5GHz Backup use SXT or combine LHG60G with af5xhd using a powerbox pro. Clie...

Mikrotik is wasting 18 months of advantage on 60 GHZ, is it possible to know if there is any hardware with 5 ghz backup in the close future? Why? UBNT will deliver such product, and there would be an AP as well, so why ask them here thinks that they now from the beginning of there 60 GHz Productlin...

Interesting, I had a discussion about this after my CRS309 video last week . I was testing, including jumbo frames and it was working fine and he said it was impossible. All that I can add to this discussion is that module revision 2.11 manufactured 2018-12-06 works well. Tested it with 1Gbit Intel...

Sorry for digging up this thread. Meanwhile the RJ10 product page lists the new revision as also supporting jumbo frames (the old one did not). I have 3 rev1 modules and 1 rev2 (happely working together). Is there a way to trade/flash/... the rev1 modules to rev2? Even rev2 is old. The actual are r...

We also have two LHGG-60ad making an important 320 meters backhaul that is rock solid. Even with heavy rain it doesn't come down and 1Gb+ aggregated is not a single issue. I am replacing all my Ignitenet 60Ghz stuff (had 4 links of them) by these Mikrotik units. Mikrotik is not only 1/4 of the cost...

Just updated 2 CCR Core Routers to 6.42.12 (Long Term) this night. One got OSPF Problems with a neighboring router which runs a 6.39 stable version. As soon as the older router is the designated OSPF Router the connected route and all routes behind the older router do not get forwarded into the netw...

1.5km extended ethernet sounds pointless when single-mode SFP's costs next to nothing today. I still prefer a structured copper inhouse installation over fiber in many places. 1. We struggle a lot with sfp problems. Some get hot, autonegotiation is often not successful, ... 2. Some watts extra 3. N...

You can buy 802.11ax routers on the shelf in retail stores already, yet zero communication from Mikrotik about their timeline... this is rather worrying. 802.11ax isn't finalized yet. You must be young. The routers on the market are "draft" ax, as in public beta. Compatibility with the fi...

is there even any AC pci cards we could test on a routerboard?

There is hardware: https://wikidevi.com/wiki/List_of_802.11ax_Hardware

But you need to convince MT to build a driver.

No new 60 ghz device with 5 ghz backup? First things first More and more, there is no wireless future in Mikrotik Product Roadmap........ Yes. No 802.11ax, not mentioned Terragraph (https://blog.mikrotik.com/announcements/mikrotik-accelerates-the-adoption-of-60-ghz-technologies-with-terragraph.html...

Don´t cry for next new Hardware, we had to wait over 12 Month for new Arm Chipsets to get running in most cases, most here had buyed 802.11n Hardware until there is no working 802.11ac available from Mikrotik, Wave2 is completely unsupported (most available devices from MT has Wave 2 Chipset). So d...

Will a new wireless driver package for 802.11ac be released in 6.45 or is it planned for a later RouterOS version? Do you have any specific information about something to happen? There are .ax Chipsets available for a while now. I guess all WISP vendors do at least some testing in Lab now. So they ...

i update to 6.44 but when i wana use ip cloud sometimes about half of time i try "Error: request Timed out" what should i do?

Send report to support@mikrotik.com including .rif File.

I know it is an old topic. Any changes which speeds up route changes/removals with big routing tables.

Esp. with a pending problem it is crazy to sit there waiting minutes until a command finishes.

There is no mention of mesh in that post. More likely, last mile as PtMP, especially with their last innovation: 180° coverage with single antenna https://mikrotik.com/product/wap_60gx3_ap And I meant that the wireless wire kit is available for a while. Terragraph is mesh. So if MT does Terragraph ...

It's available for a while already. And it's not competition, given the limited range. more like "last mile" solution.

It is announced for a while, not available. With this it is possible to jump from house to house with high speed. Given the high bandwidth several hops are possible.

https://blog.mikrotik.com/announcements ... graph.html

This is competition to fiber. High speed, higher reliability through mesh. MT: I want it now.

With ubiquiti AF HD we are very close to have 100 mb/s download speed with 10 MHz for PtP NOW for AP side with cambium we have >300 Mb/s@20 MHz using ultra dense mu-mimo technology So if DISC Lite5 ac DiscG-5acD 240mbit (if it really works) cost is 45$, what is the cost of cambium per mbit? This is...

This is not AC mode, AC mode will reach around 240Mbps on 40MHz
yeee single TCP stream 240 Mbit from 40 Mhz Mby in lab.

Still a waste of spectrum these days. Hope .ax shows up soon. >100M Capacity/10MHz is 2019.

And whooop .... back to topic ;-) @Normis Are you able to talk about 802.11ax ? At least what MUM to look at .... There are chipsets of your suppliers out there: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ax#Silicon. So I guess you have something in your lab and as you did with 60GHz you might want to...

Indoor: UniFi performs better than Capsman UniFi Devices had better Range than WAPac and CAPac Outdoor: Mikrotik with ARM Based Chipset is completely unusable, unstable Connections, ping lags, disconnects, TDMA not working with ARM, no Spectral Scan AirMax and other like Mimosa are miles away With ...

We had the same issue in amateur packet radio and it was solved in the nineties. The solution was called DAMA and I think it is much like NV2 and AirMax, maybe less a few of the special optimizations. It is unbelievable that 25 years later there still is no 802.11xx standard that covers this and ca...

LOL... Good luck with that, I'm sure manufacturers are really thrilled to publish all their secrets so they can make less money... this is simply not going to happen. Only possibility is if TDMA is part of the future official 802.11something specification. And it's a good question why this wasn't d...

I heard that they are releasing new version of RoS with airmax compatibility on 1 Apr 2019
That must be RouterOS v7 !!!

Codename: Unicorn

For sure .ax will be earlier. Think back: MT was the first with .ac.

I heard that they are releasing new version of RoS with airmax compatibility on 1 Apr 2019

+1

There is a (big) arm/nv2 thread already.
This thread is about 802.11ax. Would like to hear about it, too.

Yeah, i know how sound this. Yes, config is not a problem! default config for WAPac and linux/windows PC with broadcom chipset have problem also. I'm certified Mikrotik user :) The problem persist from one firmware to another, even if i send all necesary info to mikrotik support. Cisco support is v...

We use this port only for management in case we mess up vlan config. Guess this is the intended use. But of course no packet loss should happen.

Hello, i have problem with CRS317-1G-16S+RM on ether1 is packet loss. if i have in ether1 device linking on 10Mbit or 1Gbit everything is allright, there is no packet loss. but if i have device linking on 100Mbit i have packet loss and rises rx fcs error and rx fragment. i have three CRS317-1G-16S+...

Unfortunately we can't make the Product that supports both B43 and B48 so you would need to choose which one you would need. Any other requirements - output power, CA support, bandwidth width, etc...? B43. Output power as high as possible. We use this band esp. where 5GHz does not work out. 10/20MH...

Unfortunately we can't make the Product that supports both B43 and B48 so you would need to choose which one you would need. Any other requirements - output power, CA support, bandwidth width, etc...? B43. Output power as high as possible. We use this band esp. where 5GHz does not work out. 10/20MH...

Search found 1931 matches