MikroTik

heimdal

after one year and over , with mikrotik BGP finaly i get it off ... ask me why ? one hour with my experience with BSD and quagga from ports, and i have stable BGP from Start.Date to NOW() :) So ...i think you betta go to something other for your work ... about 400 000 routes loaded for seconds ...an...

heimdal

On your router you have two interfaces, set proxy-arp on internal iface.

And works ! 1460 for PPTP MTU/MRU is OK if you have PPPoE with 1492 MTU (in some cases i see some ISP`s set their low then 1492 but workin` )

heimdal

Help with WHAT , Sam ? With this practice "sent supout.rif" ....."sent" ..."sent" Thats the answers from MT, why just got working those features ? Support cost much and takes the time, people and other expensible resources, when product finaly working as jalopy...wreck ...

heimdal

advantz, mikrotik people must think before to give us some features... i`m realy disapointed from repeatin problems ... or fix something and crash something other ... Can i ask you to send to me conf files for quagga without you sensitive information. I have some PC here for testing purposes, and th...

heimdal

Why to send them supout ?? they have and provide links to cisco documentation! (but don`t have their implementation of BGP !!!) And ...i said this: Have RFC for BGP ? Why BGP didnt work ? Finaly i think to left Mikrotik "friendly" and not working OS. For now look at Cisco 2xxx series or so...

heimdal

with mac server (enabled by default) you do not need any IP ...just replace ip address to MAC address of your router and connect ...
i dont have a time to make screenshots for you ... too busy with some bugs in mikrotik BGP ...they make me crazy over a two months ago ...

heimdal

Try with Mac based access, in winbox in field with IP address place a mac address from mikrotik interface that you want to access and try again ...

heimdal

I`m using for eBGP, 2 ISP x 185 000 routes, thats my point of view ...

glad to see iBGP is OK ...wait for other comments cause router is in production ...i wont do mistakes..

heimdal

I have 2.9.25 with routing-test, works for me but have strange "reload" on BGP sessions once for last 48 hours. For now this is not a problem, router with P4 3GHz, 1 G RAM, 4 Intel giga ethernet (one dual + two integrated on Intel Server Board). Load 2x 185 000 routes from two ISPs for abo...

heimdal

I have working (for now) BGP router, but i see strange "ticking" in session timer. Timer holds ..and then saw fast counting 2 seconds. In time that was happen cpu load have a peak about 13, then when fast counts 2 seconds cpu load is about 3-4 ... may be should have this sound from Starcra...

heimdal

For last 30 hours i get only one error : Hold timer expired 40 minutes after midnight, then all brp peers was restarted, 30 seconds router has messages in log: Failed to open TCP connection. Operation now in progress RemoteAddr=peer1 ip RemotePort=179 Failed to open TCP connection. Operation now in ...

heimdal

try chatroom, think we get dialog window

heimdal

nikhil, you have working icq or something for instant message ...
to stop spam forum with our dialog ...
sorry guys from mt but mt chat drive me crazy

heimdal

nikhil, in terminal :

when you press double Tab you got "predict" for commands,
that mean you must

enable 0

add network=xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/xx disabled=no

and you have network advertised from your router

heimdal

nikhil , did you get routing-test from topic ???

in this version from normis - network command is back again (thats make me happy

)

heimdal

nikhil i see this parameters in my 2.9.25 with first provided routing-test,

i think you need to setup this routing-test-2.9.25.npk from topic !!!

I have 2 x 180 000 and over routes, each loaded for 30-60 seconds !!!
without this 100% cpu load.

my cpu is 3 GHz too! and 1 G ram...

heimdal

I see advertisement for my BGP router every morning. From third independent ISP that check AS in my country and i see my network is advertised properly. If you want may use ARIN/RIPE tools too ...or ask "other side" - your ISP`s to tell you what they see from BGP messages.

heimdal

sorry for this post, but i must explain to nikhil. when saw this: I checked nikhil's supout.rif and he is using the standard routing package, not test i have downloaded all_packages, next... unzip and go to directory contain *.npk files. delete routing.npk (this is normal package comming with packag...

heimdal

i use package from topic - for last 12 hours everything is OK!!! 4 BGP sessions work great for now. Thanks from me for fix and for "network" command too. nikhill for testing purposes i have another one router with different hardware (intel motherboard, with intel network adapters, intel cp...

heimdal

Gregor i have installed last version on routing-test-2.9.25.npk ( new routing test, which supposedly fixes some BGP issues: http://www.mikrotik.com/download/routing-test-2.9.25_new.zip ), and for last 12 hours BGP is still up and running without deaviations. And now i think to joy with prepends and ...

heimdal

Gregor, network is first simple way to advertise your own networks and if you add them with command - this is your networks from your router ... other ways is with "connected and static" but is not useful for small networks with mikrotik filters that i can`t successfuly run for some reason...

heimdal

With standart routing-test on 2.9.25 have problem with hold time expire. If i stay to only one ISP - no problems. If i stay with two ISP`s - bgp sessions go somwhere faaaaar away .. :) and reseting again and again ...sounds like my "dream" is to stay without internet connections :) Thanks ...

heimdal

thanks to gregor!!!

i see that one men understand what i want to say here

heimdal

apologize , may be i`m wrong with "quagga or zebra" finaly i stop to write here and test .25 BGP ...and will see .. thanks to normis and eugene for activity here. may be nikhill need to send .rif file, i don`t need ...just wait for complete features. still wait for solution about advertise...

heimdal

if you have BGP with MT and tryin` two packages you know about ... Some features of BGP protocol, software that deals with BGP, not "iron" cisco...just software, like quagga and zebra . In MT case - this is quagga. And if you see routing and routing-test features, then you see "cisco ...

heimdal

More and more people using MT for BGP!!! Why MT people not give us final working routing ? Quagga version used in MT is old. Commands is not enough, with different commands we need different examples :) If i am wrong - correct me! Quagga syntax is like cisco. Mikrotik using quagga with their own syn...

heimdal

like i said before: their OWN review for BGP (without many VTY quagga features - like commands in cisco). Don`t expect anything from Mikrotik people, i`m in trouble with BGP too. And i see in documentation they no have examples for correct configured bgp for single or multi homed router working with...

heimdal

suggest filters for outgoin bgp updates ?
may be you can explain, strange problems "one vlan filtered itself, another - can`t be filtered"

and where is missing "network=xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/xxx" in /routing ????

heimdal

i just wrote what you see: without filters bgp over two vlan connections works very strange in one of them - is correct by default ! advertised networks is only those i want , in other - my networks + all connected. i setup filter to test what goin, but still unhappy. settting to peer , setting gene...

heimdal

Still gettin trouble with multihomed BGP :) Just imagine : link to one of my ISP`s , two VLAN, two /30 networks for "country" and "international" routers, redistribute connected on mikrotik, and WITHOUT filter what we see ? In international bgp peer router not need a filter, netw...

heimdal

Thanks, but i`m confuzed about our comments here because this is just announcement for winbox with routing-test support. But this topic is over the top and i still ask how to translate cisco rules to mikrotik rules :) Those people that gave us links to cisco ...must suppose to know :) Or those peopl...

heimdal

So, i setting up one BGP link with routing test and saw what happened: work only with "redistribute connected" - on mikrotik documentation for BGP command reference is connected and static... WHY ? Again i recommend those people who wrote documentation to provide us useful primer to config...

heimdal

i`ll setup two brand new 2.9.23 to test this rules example

but still suggest mikrotik developers do not give us links to cisco

we need mikrotik syntax to setting up router properly, is not only experience with bgp or cisco

heimdal

Why don`t use some useful features from "old" routing package? In my situation i have multihomed BGP with two peers. In other side have cisco routers and their administrators told me "you don`t have filters, you send to us all from routing table" and "your networks are missi...

Search found 34 matches

just comment

about BGP

What about BGP? For MT guys, tell us when BGP should be OK..

about bgp

hmm

:)))

:)

:)

filters ?

i don`t think

BGP PROBLEM

bgp problems

BGP routing-test problem

thanks for your post

i agree with NetRaptor about BGP