Fri Apr 04, 2008 11:03 pm
We use Waverider / SR9 / XR9 in a somewhat rural environment with little to no problems.
I would suggest if you use SR9 cards to have a filter in place for the center frequency you are using.
Yes SR9 are really affected by interference, but putting the filter in place should help quite a bit.
I've noticed that if you do not have the proper queues in place on an AP with 32 users, some users will cause the latency to jump up big time, especially with heavy users(aka campers). It also depends on your GOS that you give your users as well. On 5Mhz channels you are talking about 4-5Mbit bandwidth total to all of your customers on that AP. I've had customers with just at 256Kbit connection affect the latency for all users on the AP without the proper queues. What happens usually is they are downloading quite a few different items and the pps is maxed out on their connection(p2p comes to mind).
XR9 seems to hold up better against noise/interference, we have been using xr9 instead of sr9 for all new AP's and setups. We have 4 AP's with XR9 now that run at a -91 noise floor and customers still seem to be running fine. When we first started doing wireless in the 900 Mhz arena, our noise floor would stay at -100 on our first mikrotik AP's. I do realize that noise is going to get worse as time passes by. We also had a sr9 access point with a -100 noise floor that would drop to -94 and cause clients to disconnect. Putting the filter in place helped the AP with the noise.
Mikrotik / XR9 hands down blows Waverider out of the water. As for comparing it to Canopy I do not know, I have never used any Moto equipment. There is another wireless ISP that uses a Motorola Canopy 900 AP, but it is too far away from where our access points(Maybe 5 Miles, but our terrain has rolling hills) are and we try to stay away from the Frequency they use.
Also any type of weather doesn't affect 900 Mhz enough to lose 20 db or so. During rain or even a light fog(We aren't in a fog environment), none of our connections drop because of a rise in RSSI. Now if we are talking about heavy foilage, especially some type of pine tree then yes/maybe. We have connections NLOS with trees in the way that do not drop connection on a heavy rain, and some of these i'm talking about are -80 connections not -70 or better.
Every wireless environment is different. (terrain/noise/weather)