Same here, except I have been using WDS to set up a simple bridged backhaul mesh, and as of 5.x the configuration no longer works. Note that it happens with various radios (CM9, all the r52n variations, the OmniTik & SXT), and if either or both ends of the link is running 5.x (It works fine if both ends are running 4.x.)So far every device I have WDS on (not many mind you) has issues with v5...
This does sound like the same problem I have been seeing. I never noticed whether it only happens when more than one interface uses WDS, but now that you mention it, looking at my network, the devices that "behave themselves" do have only one radio.I am having the same issue on 5.11. It gets large amounts of traffic over the WDS interfaces as soon as they register and doesnt allow me to access them any more, i have to access via Mac address and disable to WDS to get back in. Have tried upgrading to 5.16 and am still having the same issue.
This seems to work fine with two APS connected via WDS, though when i have one AP with more than one WDS interface this is when the issue arises.
When i downgrade to version 4.16 the issue is gone.
Any ideas what is causing this?
Well, I have forwarded supout files from several devices while the packet storm was going on, so I'm not sure what else to do. I'm unable to not reproduce it!we are unable to reproduce that large traffic problem when you start using WDS.
We need the simplest setup to reproduce this problem - that will help us to find the problem and fix.
Good to know! Now we just need to build a testbed for our friends in Latvia.I've been able to reproduce this consistently with 2 RB751U-2HnD's one as apbridge and the other as either apbridge or WDS slave, nothing else in the network. Usually only takes a few minutes for the storms to start.
So... what does this setting do?I have the same exact problem on my pair of RB751U-2HnD running AP Bridge mode with WDS-Bridge. Tried all the firmware including V6Beta2 but storm still observed. Only firmware 4.17 is OK.
After trying several permutation of configurations, I managed to find a way to fix this. Under Bridge Port configuration, just enable Horizon settings on WDS and WLAN interface by defining a same number for both interfaces.
And if we have devices with three radios in WDS mode, all ports on the same bridge, do you suppose we'll still have cross-talk from the other two?Do note that this Horizon settings can only be enabled on one of the two WDS nodes else traffic will somehow not pass through.
STUPENDOUS!!looks like we were able to find the loop when you connect two APs together with WDS. The fix will be added in v5.18.
Any idea on release date, as we have a very large installation due that will rely upon this.looks like we were able to find the loop when you connect two APs together with WDS. The fix will be added in v5.18.
Please email to support@mikrotik.com and provide also the Mikrotik account name - we will add you access to pre-release of the newest RouterOS version.Any idea on release date, as we have a very large installation due that will rely upon this.looks like we were able to find the loop when you connect two APs together with WDS. The fix will be added in v5.18.
36 hours without incident, and counting.Try out now the new test release that was made today.
jan/02/1970 04:43:44 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:44:45 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2D:73:7F@VAP1: disconnected, management-protection failure
jan/02/1970 04:44:45 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: disconnected, management-protection failure
jan/02/1970 04:44:45 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2D:73:7F@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:44:46 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2D:73:7D@VAP1: disconnected, management-protection failure
jan/02/1970 04:44:46 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2D:73:7D@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:44:53 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:45:04 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: disconnected, no beacons received
jan/02/1970 04:45:05 wireless,info VAP1: data from unknown device D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4, sent deauth
jan/02/1970 04:45:05 wireless,info VAP1: data from unknown device D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4, sent deauth
jan/02/1970 04:45:06 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:46:10 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: disconnected, management-protection failure
jan/02/1970 04:46:10 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:46:14 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2D:73:7D@VAP1: disconnected, management-protection failure
jan/02/1970 04:46:14 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2D:73:7D@VAP1: connected, is AP, wants WDS
jan/02/1970 04:46:36 wireless,info D6:CA:6D:2B:6C:B4@VAP1: disconnected, no beacons received
36 hours without incident, and counting.Try out now the new test release that was made today.
Disabling a radio occasionally takes the RB offline (no response via ether1, one of the bridge ports) for ~30 seconds, and enabling a radio often results in several seconds of multi-Megabit traffic over the newly-created WDS interface. But in both cases, everything settles back to normal in less than a minute.
Just upgraded to the newly-released 5.18, still looking good.36 hours without incident, and counting.Try out now the new test release that was made today.
I have been informed that the burst of traffic upon connecting is to perform an initial signal measurement; i.e., standard operating procedure.Disabling a radio occasionally takes the RB offline (no response via ether1, one of the bridge ports) for ~30 seconds, and enabling a radio often results in several seconds of multi-Megabit traffic over the newly-created WDS interface. But in both cases, everything settles back to normal in less than a minute.
I've got a few PTP shots that have that behavior. Change the channel, disable wlan1, anything that makes the link drop for more than a fraction of a second and the ether1 link drops as well.36 hours without incident, and counting.Try out now the new test release that was made today.
Disabling a radio occasionally takes the RB offline (no response via ether1, one of the bridge ports) for ~30 seconds, and enabling a radio often results in several seconds of multi-Megabit traffic over the newly-created WDS interface. But in both cases, everything settles back to normal in less than a minute.
Now it's working, thank youtry to use the wds-mode=dynamic-mesh on both boards and check again the logs.
Are you saying that I need to switch my wds-mode=dynamic to wds-mode=dynamic-mesh with no other configuration changes will fix this issue?try to use the wds-mode=dynamic-mesh on both boards and check again the logs.
name="wlan1" mtu=1500 mac-address=XX:XX:XX:13:2C:0F arp=enabled
interface-type=Atheros 11N mode=ap-bridge ssid="COP-Backhaul"
frequency=5320 band=5ghz-onlyn channel-width=20/40mhz-ht-below
scan-list=default wireless-protocol=unspecified wds-mode=dynamic
wds-default-bridge=br-backhaul wds-ignore-ssid=no bridge-mode=enabled
default-authentication=yes default-forwarding=yes default-ap-tx-limit=0
default-client-tx-limit=0 hide-ssid=no security-profile=Backhaul2
compression=no
name="Backhaul2" mode=dynamic-keys authentication-types=wpa2-eap
unicast-ciphers=aes-ccm group-ciphers=aes-ccm wpa-pre-shared-key=""
wpa2-pre-shared-key="" supplicant-identity="" eap-methods=eap-tls
tls-mode=no-certificates tls-certificate=none static-algo-0=none
static-key-0="" static-algo-1=none static-key-1="" static-algo-2=none
static-key-2="" static-algo-3=none static-key-3=""
static-transmit-key=key-0 static-sta-private-algo=none
static-sta-private-key="" radius-mac-authentication=no
radius-mac-accounting=no radius-eap-accounting=no interim-update=0s
radius-mac-format=XX:XX:XX:XX:XX:XX radius-mac-mode=as-username
radius-mac-caching=disabled group-key-update=5m
management-protection=allowed management-protection-key="1x2x3x4x"