I'm rather new user to Mikrotik, I have read all docs and some questions are still unanswered:
- why bgp has so poor performance?
- why bgp does not see restart of a peer? I have to refresh the peer
manualy on Mikrotik every time I reset its peer
- how to check what prefixes are announced to peer?
- why routing table performance is so poor? (for example - list 180.000
entries, remove some etc)
- is it possible to do ttl checking of packets?
- how to make network definition in bgp instance
- how to make null interface
- [admin@krk-r1] > /ip route remove 14235
item number too large
what to do with the above problem?
- how to list only static routes?
I use MikroTik RouterOS 2.9.22 and routing-test package.
Thanks in advance for any help.
Re: Some questions - bgp and routing
Hi!
I'll try to answer some of your questions below:
Access the CLI:
Chances are there are no hold-timer or keepalive-timer references there (or they're set to 0 or something).
Set the hold-timer to 60 and the keepalive timer to 20 in order to emulate the timers on a Cisco device.
You can view the networks you have in and also check your prefix lists that you may have attached for inbound or outbound advertisements.
Not pretty, but it could get you started to what you're trying to find.
-Rich
I'll try to answer some of your questions below:
What do you mean by "poor" performance? We're using BGP to our upstream providers without any issues (although we're only accepting the default route and not a full table).- why bgp has so poor performance?
This is something that haunted us for quite some time, until we debugged it with our upstream provider and saw that the timers weren't decrementing.- why bgp does not see restart of a peer? I have to refresh the peer
manualy on Mikrotik every time I reset its peer
Access the CLI:
Code: Select all
/routing bgp peer
print detailSet the hold-timer to 60 and the keepalive timer to 20 in order to emulate the timers on a Cisco device.
Code: Select all
set 0 hold-timer=60 keepalive-timer=20You used to be able to access Quagga via telnet from the localhost on 2.8.xx, but 2.9.xx appears to have done away with that access to BGP.- how to check what prefixes are announced to peer?
You can view the networks you have in
Code: Select all
/routing bgp network print detailI don't have any info on these...- why routing table performance is so poor? (for example - list 180.000
entries, remove some etc)
- is it possible to do ttl checking of packets?
- how to make network definition in bgp instance
I don't know if this is recommended, but I've created a bridge interface without any ports being assigned to it in order to simulate a null interface.- how to make null interface
You cannot (at least on 2.8.xx) remove a dynamic route. If you wish to prevent a route learned via BGP from being injected into your table, use prefix lists to deny it.- [admin@krk-r1] > /ip route remove 14235
item number too large
what to do with the above problem?
You could use some scripting:- how to list only static routes?
I use MikroTik RouterOS 2.9.22 and routing-test package.
Thanks in advance for any help.
Code: Select all
:foreach route in [/ip route find static=yes] do [/ip route print from=$route]-Rich
Re: Some questions - bgp and routing
I mean that I have Pentium III 1.7 GHz machine with Mikrotik and whole BGP list is loaded about 30 minutes!!! Quagga on the same machine loads all prefixes in abount 30 seconds.Hi!What do you mean by "poor" performance? We're using BGP to our upstream providers without any issues (although we're only accepting the default route and not a full table).- why bgp has so poor performance?
Thanks, that should be helpful, however I think that mikrotik should see tcp reset packets and imidiatly reset the session not waiting to time out.Set the hold-timer to 60 and the keepalive timer to 20 in order to emulate the timers on a Cisco device.- why bgp does not see restart of a peer? I have to refresh the peer
manualy on Mikrotik every time I reset its peerCode: Select allset 0 hold-timer=60 keepalive-timer=20
That is not the answer. For now Mikrotik is amateur and cannot act a professional router. Such router needs sh ip bg nei X.Y.W.Z ad command and full other bgp functionality.You used to be able to access Quagga via telnet from the localhost on 2.8.xx, but 2.9.xx appears to have done away with that access to BGP.- how to check what prefixes are announced to peer?
You can view the networks you have inand also check your prefix lists that you may have attached for inbound or outbound advertisements.Code: Select all/routing bgp network print detail
It's still a trick or hack, I prefer using documented solutions.I don't know if this is recommended, but I've created a bridge interface without any ports being assigned to it in order to simulate a null interface.- how to make null interface
No, the route number 14235 was static - I have checked itYou cannot (at least on 2.8.xx) remove a dynamic route. If you wish to prevent a route learned via BGP from being injected into your table, use prefix lists to deny it.- [admin@krk-r1] > /ip route remove 14235
item number too large
what to do with the above problem?
But Mikrotik does not accept the input.
Thanks, that should be helpful!You could use some scripting:- how to list only static routes?Not pretty, but it could get you started to what you're trying to find.Code: Select all:foreach route in [/ip route find static=yes] do [/ip route print from=$route]
Gregor
Re: Some questions - bgp and routing
Sorry, can't help you there. We only accept the default route from our upstream peers (one per city) and redistribute that default route with a lower priority to the other cities. That way the upstream for a city is always it's upstream peer and falls back to our fiber between cities if the upstream peer fails.I mean that I have Pentium III 1.7 GHz machine with Mikrotik and whole BGP list is loaded about 30 minutes!!! Quagga on the same machine loads all prefixes in abount 30 seconds.
I'm not an authority on BGP, but from what I understand, BGP does not maintain an established connection.Thanks, that should be helpful, however I think that mikrotik should see tcp reset packets and imidiatly reset the session not waiting to time out.Set the hold-timer to 60 and the keepalive timer to 20 in order to emulate the timers on a Cisco device.Code: Select allset 0 hold-timer=60 keepalive-timer=20
The keepalive-timer sends out a keepalive packet to the remote host upon expiration if no packets have been received from the remote host. Any packets received from the remote host reset the keepalive-timer.
The hold-timer sets how long can go between received packets from the peer before closing the session due to keepalive failure.
Setting hold-timer to 60 and keepalive-time to 20, 2 keepalive packets will be sent to try to establish that the BGP session is still up. If, after 60 seconds, no reply is received, BGP drops the session.
I agree that a command line interface to the BGP and OSPF functions is necessary... and was provided (though not actually documented - like the hold-timer and keepalive-timer) in RouterOS 2.8.xx, but has been removed in 2.9.xx to my knowledge.That is not the answer. For now Mikrotik is amateur and cannot act a professional router. Such router needs sh ip bg nei X.Y.W.Z ad command and full other bgp functionality.
The null interface on a Cisco (or other router) is the same kind of trick or hack... It's an interface that not used for actual traffic. You create one on a Cisco and reference it as Null0 (or whatever) and I create one on a MikroTik and reference it as null. Granted, it is not an official "null interface", but performs the exact same function.- how to make null interfaceIt's still a trick or hack, I prefer using documented solutions.I don't know if this is recommended, but I've created a bridge interface without any ports being assigned to it in order to simulate a null interface.
After all, this is just my advice and/or opinions... take them or leave them
Ah... perhaps the remove command is looking for a different integer size than the add/print commands or something. That would have to be resolved by MikroTik support. But, you could get the route reference using a technique like below for finding all the static routes and remove it by reference instead of route number.No, the route number 14235 was static - I have checked it
But Mikrotik does not accept the input.
Yes, the scripting is quite powerful (for a CLI) on the MikroTiks. Allows you to script almost anything that you can do manually, if you know the steps to take to get the desired result.Thanks, that should be helpful!You could use some scripting:Not pretty, but it could get you started to what you're trying to find.Code: Select all:foreach route in [/ip route find static=yes] do [/ip route print from=$route]
Good luck!
-Rich
Re: Some questions - bgp and routing
It does. BGP uses TCP connections on port 179. When BGP router receives TCP reset it MUST close the session and clear all routes immediately!I'm not an authority on BGP, but from what I understand, BGP does not maintain an established connection.
-Rich
It can't wait any second. I use Mikrotik not for fun. I want router, not a toy.
Re: Some questions - bgp and routing
Is a TCP RESET not causing the RIB to update? If it is not, send a bug report to mikrotik because it used to and should.It does. BGP uses TCP connections on port 179. When BGP router receives TCP reset it MUST close the session and clear all routes immediately!I'm not an authority on BGP, but from what I understand, BGP does not maintain an established connection.
-Rich
It can't wait any second. I use Mikrotik not for fun. I want router, not a toy.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 54 guests