My setup:
RB751G-2HnD
Draytek Vigor 120 PPPoE ADSL modem (UK model) to UK ISP running PPPoA
I purchased these about 3 years ago.
I have been upgrading ROS every few months.
For the first 2 years PPPoE achieved uptimes measured in weeks or months, up to
and including ROS 6.18
For the last year, I have noticed many PPPoE disconnections followed by immediate
reconnections, running ROS post 6.18. This is according to the logs from
my ISP to which I have access. Typical uptimes are a few minutes to several
hours. The reason given for the disconnection in the logs is usually "port error"
or "user request".
These reconnections screw up Youtube videos or BBC iPlayer downloads or
any other bulk download. This morning a download from iPlayer kept
on stopping. The ROS version was 6.32.3. I downgraded to 6.18 and
iPlayer worked again. I did not change any other configuration.
I've read the changelogs for ROS and I see nothing to indicate the code
for PPPoE has chaned, so it is a bit of a mystery why PPPoE is
so unstable post 6.18
I've kept a diary of ROS installs and ISP logs and there is definite
correlation between PPPoE instability and ROS version. I have
run 6.18 for roughly half the time in the past year.