It is a problem of always, the problem has not been solved and has been closed for a long time.

I am orrible, in hotspot list and ARP. the mac adress of the "Station Router" are duplicated and prensentan ip private and publicos.esto is a total disorder.

I have attached images.
Someone who could resolve this issue please be kind to share the solution.

please explain your topology with more details.
and do use and copy/past result here.

I guess, the 'station router' is a non Mikrotik-device?
Then you cannot achieve transparent bridging. Thus the MAC-adress of the clients will be MAC-NATed to the MAC-address of the 'station-router'

what is wireless mode on ap and station?

I guess, the 'station router' is a non Mikrotik-device?
Then you cannot achieve transparent bridging. Thus the MAC-adress of the clients will be MAC-NATed to the MAC-address of the 'station-router'

I understand you, thank you for responding.
some are mikrotik sxt and others are ubnt litebeam. the sxt and litebeam is in station mode and at the same time router, behind these is a simple swich and they connect the computers by cable.

please explain your topology with more details.
and do use

Code: Select all

export hide-sensitive

and copy/past result here.

Good morning. thanks for answering.

The ominitk is router hotspot with ip 192.168.34.1/24
the clients are sxt and litebeam (enter the internet by wlan 192.168.34.2, nat by ether1 192.168.200.1 and also grant DHCP).

The sxt and litebeam are configured as station, do nat masking, and DHCP.

I connect a simple swich to the sxt and litebeam.

The desktop computers are physically connected to the Swich.

computers have automatic ips granted by DHCP from Sxt
192.168.200.2
192.168.200.3
192.168.200.x

It is normal for this topology.