You want me to disrupt the connection to show you proof?I don't believe you.
Proof?
Yes but that should put the pppoe interface into connecting state but it isn't.The pppoe tunnel, should and will go up as long as the pppoe server responds to the discovery messages of the pppoe client and all the stages get completed successfully.
https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:I ... _Operation
Turn on the PPP logging and post the logs. Those attachments don't show much that can be used for diagnostics.Here are the attachments.