Page 1 of 1
No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2023 5:24 pm
by Nexon
Hello MikroTik,
Why there are no more the following wireless tools:
1. /interface wireless sniffer;
2. /interface wireless snooper;
3. /interface wireless spectral-scan;
4. /interface wireless spectral-history;
Why they are missing in RouterOS V7, WifiWave2?
Do you plan to get them back?
Thank you.
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 2:14 am
by rolo95
is it my perception
or MT are just looking to the other way regarding wireless subjects ?
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 2:18 am
by anav
Hello MikroTik,
Why there are no more the following wireless tools:
1. /interface wireless sniffer;
2. /interface wireless snooper;
3. /interface wireless spectral-scan;
4. /interface wireless spectral-history;
Why they are missing in RouterOS V7, WifiWave2?
Do you plan to get them back?
Thank you.
You are close, just get on a train to Riga and go ask........
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 8:08 am
by normis
wifiwave2 package for 802.11ax (WiFI6) hardware is not made by MikroTik anymore, it uses the Qualcomm driver from chip manufacturer. You get much faster support for new chips, increased speed, a lot of new protocols, and possibly even much faster time to WiFi7 adoption. In turn, you lose some MikroTik custom made toys. Some of them we try to bring back, some of that is not possible. And also, some functions are not even supported by new chips themselves.
We do keep working on the new package and some things are coming back (like CAPsMAN etc).
P.S: sniffer already returned:
https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/ ... -Sniffer.1
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 8:22 am
by nichky
3. /interface wireless spectral-scan;
4. /interface wireless spectral-history;
extremely we need that feature on netmetal, sxt and some similar devices.
what is the point using that feature on
map?
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 11:43 am
by pe1chl
Those devices do not use the new drivers. And on older drivers, the features were not available on all chips either...
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 6:25 pm
by r00t
Lack of spectral scan is not related to wave2 but because Mikrotik started using cheapest grade of 802.11ac/ax chips that doesn't support that feature.
Just look what's Ubiquity doing with exactly same radio chipset with advanced features enabled: Spectrum scans, QAM constellation views, TDMA, ...
As for wifi2, it's sad to see these are basically SOHO grade locked down drivers, with limited options comparable to what you get on any home AP.
I think this is the main reason we haven't seen any new outdoor/WISP hardware for a long time, mostly because with current wifi2 drivers it would be a complete joke, can't even make a transparent link with it.
Long time ago amount of control, customization options and tools for WIFI were main reasons for buying Mikrotik WISP products, but that's long gone.
There is really no advantage to getting Mikrotik WIFI anymore, unless you really need all in one device or for special management purposes.
Otherwise other vendors have APs that have more chains and are 2 generations ahead for pretty much same price. And configuration options are same as what you get with Mikrotik, now that you are forced to use wifi2 on new products. Yes, configuration often sucks compared to using Winbox, but if everything works, you do that only once.
So buying Mikrotik for routing, switching? YES. But for WIFI in 2023? NOPE!
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2023 10:08 pm
by gotsprings
"...in 2023"
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2023 1:23 am
by jondavy
wifiwave2 package for 802.11ax (WiFI6) hardware is not made by MikroTik anymore, it uses the Qualcomm driver from chip manufacturer. You get much faster support for new chips, increased speed, a lot of new protocols, and possibly even much faster time to WiFi7 adoption. In turn, you lose some MikroTik custom made toys. Some of them we try to bring back, some of that is not possible. And also, some functions are not even supported by new chips themselves.
We do keep working on the new package and some things are coming back (like CAPsMAN etc).
P.S: sniffer already returned:
https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/ ... -Sniffer.1
Normis Please create for us a spectral-history using the freq-usage , even if it is extremely slow to do the scanning, but it will be much more useful
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Wed Jun 28, 2023 5:20 pm
by marekm
Will 4-address mode (station-bridge/WDS, compatible with the older 802.11n/ac devices) be implemented with the new wifiwave2 drivers? Or is it no longer supported by the new chips?
Some nice new integrated outdoor WiFi 6E radios would be welcome too.
Re: No more wireless tools: snooper,sniff,spectral-scan and spectral-history
Posted: Tue Aug 06, 2024 3:05 pm
by gabrielrocha
If this features isn't availble, how the devices choose the best channel for working when you set "auto" on channel config?