Why make firmware for wifi support, if some routers cannot do this in hardware?Why then make firmware with IoT support if it cannot do this in hardware?
I do not understand why even make additional packages for some Mikrotik devices if they do not support it at the hardware level. Or they support, but there is no information in the public domain on how to set it up.Why make firmware for wifi support, if some routers cannot do this in hardware?Why then make firmware with IoT support if it cannot do this in hardware?
IOT is an option, and additional package, that is usefull if the proper hardware is choosen.
I'm not talking about these few devices. Everything is clear with them. They support such technologies in hardware.I don't have any of these: https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/UM/IoT+productsWhy then make firmware with IoT support if it cannot do this in hardware?
What role does Mikrotik play in this scheme? Does it handle scripts? What does it do if your MQTT broker is running on another device? And you write that you work through wi-fi. Have you configured ESP-now? Or do you work on a regular Wi-Fi network? If in the usual, then these are large losses in electricity. BLE, LoRa and ESP-Now can cut power costs, but how to set it up on Mikrotik?But still can connect the MT router ROS 7 with IOT optional software, to a MQTT broker (like Mosquitto) , that runs in a Docker container,Why then make firmware with IoT support if it cannot do this in hardware?
independent container or part of Home Assistant, (which in my case is wifi based) and runs on ...
Raspberry Pi, Odroid N2+, Synology NAS, hAP ac3 , laptop, and a selected set of ESP32 and ESP8266 based devices and boards
For other protocols and conversions I will need other hardware ...
additional packages .... are just compiled for all devices AFAIK. There is seldom something that is not in all ROS images, unless it is CPU platform specific (like Zerotier for ARM only)I do not understand why even make additional packages for some Mikrotik devices if they do not support it at the hardware level.
Maybe I'm not even expressing myself correctly. Mikrotik can support these technologies in hardware. But there are no drivers. Without writing drivers and having them in the firmware, the presence of a hardware capability becomes useless.additional packages .... are just compiled for all devices AFAIK. There is seldom something that is not in all ROS images, unless it is CPU platform specific (like Zerotier for ARM only)
The firmware images are not MT device specific but are built per CPU platform.
MT router is not the central server for IOT. MQTT broker on another device? Quite common setup, no? Some even use a MQTT broker in the cloud.What role does Mikrotik play in this scheme? Does it handle scripts? What does it do if your MQTT broker is running on another device? And you write that you work through wi-fi. Have you configured ESP-now? Or do you work on a regular Wi-Fi network? If in the usual, then these are large losses in electricity. BLE, LoRa and ESP-Now can cut power costs, but how to set it up on Mikrotik?
It's not even about where the MQTT broker is.MT router is not the central server for IOT. MQTT broker on another device? Quite common setup, no? Some even use a MQTT broker in the cloud.
That is, as I expected, you have a regular Wi-Fi network. You have not set up a point-to-point connection as you did for ESP-Now. Thus, you have a very high consumption of electricians. For IoT, this is not a good practice.For me MT devices just integrade with MQTT today, and do carry the wifi backbone for the devices. (In wifi there is no relay function in the IoT nodes as with Z-wave or Zigbee)
For example, let's say we use two esp-now devices. Relatively speaking, let the radius of action of the esp-now device be 20m. These devices are located at a distance of 100m from each other. And we have some kind of MT with a range of 150m. How to use it to transfer information to the server? If we had more devices with esp-now, then several scenarios could be used: “master” sending data to multiple “slaves”, “slave” receiving data from multiple “masters”, two-way communication between boards.For me MT devices just integrade with MQTT today, and do carry the wifi backbone for the devices. (In wifi there is no relay function in the IoT nodes as with Z-wave or Zigbee)