Page 1 of 1

Broken compatibility / wrong SFP ↔ RJ45 1G transceiver temperature since RouterOS > 7.7

Posted: Thu Jun 29, 2023 9:12 pm
by sh4444dow
The compatibility with all my SFP ↔ RJ45 1G transceivers seems to be completely broken since RouterOS > 7.7

Transceiver reference (https://fr.aliexpress.com/item/4000014498661.html) :
  • Seller : ONTi
  • Vendor Part Number : GLC-LH-SMD
  • Vendor Name : CISCO
  • Vendor Serial : FNS19200G05

RouterOS 7.7
The transceiver is well detected and link OK but without temperature
router_os_7.7.png

RouterOS 7.8
The transceiver is not detected at all
router_os_7.8.png

RouterOS 7.9.2
The transeceiver is detected but no link detected
router_os_7.9.2.png

RouterOS 7.10.1
The transceiver is detected and link is finally detected... but... temperature is detected as 255°C
I found a workaround to set `SFP Shutdown Temperature` at 999°C but it not clean and it is clearly a RouterOS bug.
Morover, the transceiver is not anymore plug-and-play and detected as is, I had to disable Auto negociation for link to be OK...
router_os_7.10.1.png
router_os_7.10.1_auto_negociation.png

Another person detects a similar problem but with a DAC cable viewtopic.php?t=197285

Sincerely,

sh4444dow

Re: Broken compatibility / wrong SFP ↔ RJ45 1G transceiver temperature since RouterOS > 7.7

Posted: Wed Jul 05, 2023 11:44 pm
by sh4444dow
No response :shock: ?

Re: Broken compatibility / wrong SFP ↔ RJ45 1G transceiver temperature since RouterOS > 7.7

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2023 11:36 pm
by MakroTok
I have a similar issue. The working setup on my RB5009UG+S+ is based on 7.7 and uses a SFP (Zyxel PMG3000-D20B), had to skip 7.8 and 7.9 since the SFP was not recognized.
With 7.10.2 the SFP is shut down due to temperature, but the SFP is no hotter than 51° at anytime ...

Re: Broken compatibility / wrong SFP ↔ RJ45 1G transceiver temperature since RouterOS > 7.7

Posted: Wed Aug 02, 2023 8:47 pm
by Zig
Same issue here !!
downgrade to 7.06 to keep DAC twinax Cable (FS.com Generic) works again ...

since version 7.06 the pblm doesn't seem to be fixed in stable versions.
Can you check the Temperature data part? and fix the pblm because the ports are disabled and make the switch inoperable (CRS312).

Re: Broken compatibility / wrong SFP ↔ RJ45 1G transceiver temperature since RouterOS > 7.7  [SOLVED]

Posted: Tue Sep 26, 2023 6:13 pm
by sh4444dow
It seems to be fixed since 7.11 (4 major version after...)...
There are so many SERIOUS breaking changes and bugs that appeared since RouterOS 7.7... What are you doing mikrotik....
sfp-temperature.png