I would like to vlan 10 to live on site 1 and be able to be traversed to site 2 so I can tag switch ports on site 2. Would eoip be a good option for this?

I have equipment that needs to be in the same subnet in order for redundancy to work.

Thnaks

Hello
Send your network diagram then we can help you better

EoIP is a great way to bridge L2 across a L3 network

EOIP is grate but it use more hardware resource than VPLS.use VPLS for bridging your networks...