MikroTik

Ovpn in the bridge is still not working
[Ticket#2014051466000539]

Ovpn in the bridge is still not working
[Ticket#2014051466000539]

OVPN and bridge? How?
You can bridge only interfaces with MAC addresses or PPP interfaces with enabled BCP (Bridge Control Protocol).
So i do not see how that's a bug

Ovpn in the bridge is still not working
[Ticket#2014051466000539]

OVPN and bridge? How?
You can bridge only interfaces with MAC addresses or PPP interfaces with enabled BCP (Bridge Control Protocol).
So i do not see how that's a bug

interface ovpn-server server set mode=ethernet
ppp profile set 0 bridge=bridge1


ROS in <6.8 works
in ROS 6.8 6.9 6.10 6.11 6.12 6.13 not working

Ulypka, you should have bcp enabled on both sides of PPP (OpenVPN) tunnel.

Ovpn in the bridge is still not working
interface ovpn-server server set mode=ethernet
ppp profile set 0 bridge=bridge1

ROS in <6.8 works
in ROS 6.8 6.9 6.10 6.11 6.12 6.13 not working

Not tested in 6.13 but can confirm in older version bug is you can access to every device in network but not on device where is OpenVPN server like device where is server not in bridge.

Ticket#2014032466000827 open 24.3.2014 for now support not response on this ticket.
Open new ticket Ticket#2014051266000801 12.5.2014. for now noting from MT.

Ulypka, you should have bcp enabled on both sides of PPP (OpenVPN) tunnel.

confirm bridge with two sides work on MT

and what to do if I connect from windows?

Ulypka there is no such feature! It is not a bug! Windows doesn't support any tunnel bridging, it is RouterOS-to-RouterOS feature (and RouterOS-to-Cisco)

Ulypka there is no such feature! It is not a bug! Windows doesn't support any tunnel bridging, it is RouterOS-to-RouterOS feature

But in older version works , also windows to windows work, also in my case only problem is MT device where is server other devices in bridged network work. Problem is happen when MT introduce new PPP package.

del.

Ulypka there is no such feature! It is not a bug! Windows doesn't support any tunnel bridging, it is RouterOS-to-RouterOS feature (and RouterOS-to-Cisco)

http://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php ... 96#p426396


just flashing from 6.7 to 6.11
and stops working

rextended, I will check for the issue, and try to find out why it is not fixed yet.
And we will try to fix it at 6.14 version.

Check Ticket#2014032466000827 you have explanation how to try.

sergejs
As i understand it will not be correct (that would work in version 6.7)?

Ulypka there is no such feature! It is not a bug! Windows doesn't support any tunnel bridging, it is RouterOS-to-RouterOS feature

But in older version works , also windows to windows work, also in my case only problem is MT device where is server other devices in bridged network work. Problem is happen when MT introduce new PPP package.

No, it doesn't. you can't get proper MAC-level communications to Windows in any version of RouterOS, maybe you had some setup that had similar behaviour but i'm sure it is not proper bridging. you can simply see this enabling debug logs and see that BCp protocol is not supported by windows client.

macgaiver
I have worked with this configuration version 5.11 to 6.7 on any computer
and 6.8 all broke

http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/OpenVPN
Windows
client of a bridged server (tap)

proto tcp-client

remote openvpn.example.com 1194 # Remote OpenVPN Servername or IP address
dev tap

nobind
persist-key

tls-client
ca ca.crt # Root certificate in the same directory as this configuration file.
cert keys/client.crt
key keys/client.key

apparently do not even try packages sent

Ulypka there is no such feature! It is not a bug! Windows doesn't support any tunnel bridging, it is RouterOS-to-RouterOS feature

But in older version works , also windows to windows work, also in my case only problem is MT device where is server other devices in bridged network work. Problem is happen when MT introduce new PPP package.

No, it doesn't. you can't get proper MAC-level communications to Windows in any version of RouterOS, maybe you had some setup that had similar behaviour but i'm sure it is not proper bridging. you can simply see this enabling debug logs and see that BCp protocol is not supported by windows client.

Not need full layer 2 support but working like in older version is ok. My configuration is simple MT OpenVPN server in bridge and Windows OpenVPN client for me everything is working only MT device very is server is not accessible. I use OpenVPN because have some location where need to use connection trough proxy server, but now administrators on that network open port for 1723 an gre and everything is switching to PPTP.
But why something is working in older version not working in new version.

And one more thing support not answering on that ticket more that 2 months if support say ok that in new PPP package can be don't ok I can live witout it, but not answering on ticket is not professional because I insist to this feature working.

support
As i understand it will not be correct (that would work in version 6.7)?

Same problem here, just tried with 6.15. Has someone got any feedback from Mikrotik about this yet?

I have confirmed this does work in 6.7. I made the mistake of upgrading a ovpn concentrator to 6.15 from 5.26 needless to say all of the connections stopped functioning.


Any update of when or if this will be corrected. I could not even ping the ip of the remote ovpn-out interface after upgrading.